Tuesday, March 15, 2011

Macbeth the Movie: Where is the Love?

Courtesy of Netflix
I began watching the 2010 PBS version of Macbeth today, with the hope that my focus might shine through in some way. In the hour that I was able to watch (all I had time for today), I was sadly disappointed. Maybe this is what lends the play such a dreary, dark aspect. Of course, the movie did nothing to improve this feeling.

It has a World War II setting, although what side Macbeth fights for is pretty ambiguous. Duncan sort of resembles Hitler, so it's possible they are representing the German side. So far, everything has taken place in barracks made of cement with very little visual interest.

Some things I think the movie has done well so far:
  • The setting is very bland and really forces the audience to pay attention completely to the actors. Yet it lends itself to visual interest and aesthetic when necessary.
  • The witches were spot on. They don't have actual beards, but they were dressed as war nurses, so when they pulled their face masks down, they looked like beards. Their little satanic rituals were pretty realistic and unnerving. 
  • It captures the raw violence of the play. I don't think they're overexaggerating this part, which is a little sickening.
  • Lady Macbeth has the perfect amount of sex appeal and insanity. She's pretty but also skeletal looking. 
  • The production design is very sparse, but they've done a good job. 
  • I also recommend this movie to anyone doing sound. It's really interesting how they chose to do sound effects.

Some things not so good:
  • Some parts are just a little too...creepy. For instance, the witches pull a heart out of a dead man's body to use for their ritual. Did not need to see that.
  • The porter was a little too crude. Just not my cup of tea.
All in all, it has been interesting to look at, and I will do a deeper analysis when I finish the movie. 

Comments (6)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
You would suggest this to people doing sound? I'm doing sound, and your idea seems pretty interesting. I'm looking into how sound influences the understanding of the text, how the words are enhanced by the music, sound effects, voice intonations, etc. In case I don't have time to watch the entire special, do you think that there are one or two parts that would be more interesting to watch sound effects wise? Thank you so much for the pointer!
1 reply · active 733 weeks ago
Let's see, about 45 minutes in, Macbeth and Lady Macbeth go around and kill the king. That's probably the best part, because there are these weird shrieking noises, which give it a really creepy feel. That's the best part so far, but the first few minutes are also an interesting way to do Shakespeare, because the man giving a monologue is dying, so it really affects the distribution of his lines.

It's on netflix online. Just so you know!
How were you hoping to tie Macbeth in with your focus? I'm intrigued.
1 reply · active 732 weeks ago
Haha well, I was going to try and examine Macbeth's marriage with Lady Macbeth. Their relationship is pretty much businesslike in the movie though. There is some sensuality, but in the tiniest degree. And it comes off as really creepy. Plus, in the movie, Macbeth is way older than his wife. They both were cast a little older than I was expecting.
Just looking at the movie poster of Patrick Stewart with blood on his hands creeps me out! Sounds like a pretty interesting adaptation.
1 reply · active 732 weeks ago
It is interesting! Although I do have to say that after watching the whole thing, it should probably be rated R. Mostly because of the witches! Almost too realistic.

Post a new comment

Comments by